DoorDash, the popular food delivery service, has agreed to pay $16.75 million as part of a settlement following an investigation into its payment practices. New York Attorney General Letitia James led the inquiry, which found that the company had misused customer tips between May 2017 and September 2019. The investigation revealed that DoorDash used customer tips to reduce its own wage obligations instead of passing the full amount of the tips directly to delivery workers, known as Dashers.

How DoorDash Misled Workers and Customers

The problem began with DoorDash’s pay model, which guaranteed a set payout for each delivery. However, instead of adding customer tips to the base pay as promised, DoorDash included them in the total pay amount, meaning that in many cases, the tip would simply replace a portion of the guaranteed amount. As a result, even though customers were told their tips were going directly to Dashers, the workers often did not receive the full amount of the tip.

For example, if a customer tipped $5, the $5 could be deducted from the amount DoorDash would have paid the worker, leaving the total pay unchanged. This practice was in stark contrast to the company’s assurances to customers that Dashers received 100% of their tips.

The misleading practice was not only harmful to workers but also deceived customers who believed they were providing an extra benefit to Dashers. DoorDash’s own statements promised transparency, but the reality was much different. The company failed to provide workers with their full earnings, and it caused frustration among many Dashers who felt they were being shortchanged.

Settlement Terms and Compensation for Workers

As part of the settlement, DoorDash has agreed to pay $16.75 million to workers who were impacted by the misleading payment model. In addition to the $16.75 million, the company will pay $1 million in administrative costs to distribute the funds. Some affected workers could receive up to $14,000, depending on the number of deliveries they completed during the period in question.

The deceptive payment model had a significant impact on workers. It affected over 63,000 Dashers in New York alone and covered 11 million deliveries made between May 2017 and September 2019. This case is not the first time DoorDash has faced scrutiny over its payment practices. Similar settlements have already been reached in Washington, D.C., for $2.5 million in 2020 and in Illinois for $11.25 million in 2024.

These settlements reflect the growing concern over the treatment of gig economy workers, many of whom rely on platforms like DoorDash to earn a living. While DoorDash has promised to change its policies, the company’s previous actions have raised serious questions about how well gig economy companies prioritize their workers’ rights and earnings.

Reaction from Attorney General Letitia James

New York Attorney General Letitia James strongly condemned DoorDash’s actions, stating that the company “misled customers and shortchanged hardworking Dashers who deserved their full earnings.” She emphasized that the settlement was a crucial step toward ensuring that gig economy workers are treated fairly and that companies like DoorDash are held accountable for their actions. “This settlement ensures accountability and fair treatment moving forward,” she added.

James’s statement reflects broader concerns about how companies in the gig economy treat their workers. Many gig workers are classified as independent contractors, which means they often miss out on benefits and protections that employees typically receive. This leaves workers more vulnerable to exploitation, as shown by DoorDash’s previous payment practices.

DoorDash’s Response and Changes to Payment System

In response to the investigation and the settlement, DoorDash has stated that it has made changes to its payment system since 2019. The company now claims that all tips given to Dashers are passed on directly to the workers, without being deducted from their base pay. DoorDash also stated that its former payment model was properly disclosed, but it acknowledged the need to improve transparency and ensure fair treatment for workers.

“We remain committed to fair and transparent earnings,” said DoorDash in a statement. The company added that it has taken steps to ensure such issues will not happen again in the future.

While DoorDash claims to have fixed the problem, the settlement and ongoing scrutiny highlight the importance of holding gig economy companies accountable for their treatment of workers. As more people turn to platforms like DoorDash for part-time or full-time work, it’s essential that companies provide fair pay and transparent practices to avoid further legal and public backlash.

The Growing Scrutiny of Gig Economy Companies

This case is part of a larger trend of increased scrutiny of gig economy companies and how they compensate their workers. In recent years, workers across various industries have pushed for better pay, benefits, and working conditions. Gig economy companies, including Uber, Lyft, and DoorDash, have faced legal challenges over issues such as misclassification of workers, wage theft, and lack of benefits.

Governments and regulatory bodies have begun taking a more active role in addressing these concerns. The settlements with DoorDash in New York, Washington, D.C., and Illinois reflect growing concern over the rights of gig workers. These actions may lead to more oversight of gig economy companies and stricter regulations aimed at protecting workers.

Conclusion

DoorDash’s $16.75 million settlement is a significant step toward holding the company accountable for its misleading payment practices. The settlement will provide compensation for workers who were denied their full tips and help restore trust in the gig economy. However, it also raises important questions about the treatment of gig workers and the responsibilities of companies that rely on them.

As DoorDash and other companies in the gig economy continue to grow, it will be essential for regulators to ensure that workers are treated fairly and that companies prioritize transparency and accountability. The DoorDash settlement is a clear message that companies must do better when it comes to compensating their workers.

For more updates on gig economy issues and other business news, visit Wallstreet Storys.