A tribunal has ruled that the Premier League’s sponsorship rules from 2021 to 2024 are “void and unenforceable.” This decision follows an arbitration panel’s findings that questioned key parts of the Associated Party Transaction (APT) rules. The case was brought by Manchester City, which argued that the rules were unfair.
Despite this ruling, the Premier League says that its current APT rules are still valid. The league introduced these rules to stop clubs from signing inflated sponsorship deals with companies linked to their owners.
Background on APT Rules
In December 2021, the Premier League created APT rules. These rules came after Newcastle United’s Saudi-led takeover. The goal was to stop clubs from using sponsorship deals to increase revenue unfairly. The league gained the power to review deals and ensure they followed financial rules.
Many clubs supported the rules. But Manchester City, Newcastle, Nottingham Forest, and Aston Villa were against them. In November 2023, the Premier League changed the APT rules. Despite protests from some clubs, the league went forward with its plans.
Now, the tribunal has ruled that the original APT rules were unlawful in three ways. Because these problems cannot be separated from the rules, the entire set has been ruled invalid.
Big Setback for the Premier League
This ruling is a major blow to the Premier League. It confirms that the APT rules in place until November 2024 were invalid. Any club that faced penalties under these rules may now seek compensation.
Some experts believe the league could face financial claims worth millions of pounds. The ruling also raises concerns about Premier League chief Richard Masters. He pushed for rule changes, despite warnings from Manchester City and Aston Villa. Now, critics are questioning his decisions.
Premier League’s Response
The Premier League insists that its new APT rules are still valid. It says that the tribunal did not rule on their legality.
“The tribunal’s decision does not impact the new rules. The tribunal has not ruled on their effectiveness. A club’s potential gain from this ruling depends on another legal challenge filed last month,” the Premier League stated.
The league also said that all clubs must continue following the APT system. This includes fair market value checks for sponsorship deals and shareholder loans.
Manchester City’s Legal Battles
Manchester City has long opposed the Premier League’s financial rules. The club argues that these rules are unfair. Now, after this ruling, City has criticized the Premier League for misleading clubs about the rules.
In early February, Manchester City launched another legal challenge. This time, the club is arguing that the updated APT rules from November are also unlawful. If the tribunal agrees, the Premier League could face a serious crisis.
Potential Consequences for the League
The Premier League has already spent millions on legal battles. Now, it may have to deal with more legal costs and compensation claims. If other clubs join the fight, the financial impact could grow.
If the APT rules are removed, clubs like Manchester City and Newcastle will benefit. They could sign big sponsorship deals without restrictions. But other clubs fear this will hurt the league’s competitive balance.
At the same time, the Premier League is dealing with another issue. Manchester City is facing 115 charges for breaking financial rules. The club denies any wrongdoing. A ruling on this case could also have a big impact on the league.
As these legal battles continue, the future of the Premier League’s financial rules remains uncertain. Clubs, investors, and fans will be watching closely to see what happens next.
For more sports updates, visit Wallstreet Storys.
